Andaz 5th Avenue

By Terry Trucco

At a glance: For a certain type of visitor – book lovers, history buffs, Breakfast at Tiffany’s fans – a hotel room overlooking the New York Public Library defines bliss.

Just don’t expect the inside of the Andaz 5th Avenue to look like the venerable limestone pile that’s visible through it’s enormous Fifth Avenue windows. In keeping with the formula for the sleek Hyatt-without-mentioning-the-name business/lifestyle boutique chain, Andaz 5th is cool, contemporary and chic in a 21st-century way, more minimal than maximal, and just possibly the best Andaz of the bunch.

The white-on-white guest rooms designed by designer Tony Chi are elegant (or really spare, depending on your taste). That understated chic extends to the public spaces including the inviting lobby seating area, which showcase luxurious materials like basalt and black-and-white-washed poplar and are practical and smart instead of cozy.

The hotel boasts an eye-catching art collection and ties with the local art community. There’s also a daily wine hour where guests can mingle. But like other Andaz outposts, 5th adds a hefty daily destination fee ($40) that can be helpful or annoying depending on how you use the perks (2 free City Bike passes, daily newspapers, 20 percent off meals at the hotel restaurant and 10 percent off at the New York Public Library gift shop for starters).

We also like the hotel’s LEED silver certification as a green building. True, it’s easier for new properties to achieve this status than old, but like much about Andaz 5th, it’s appealing and admirable.

Rooms: They’re big (the smallest have king-size beds) and loft-like with 12-foot ceilings, enormous windows and white walls. Hard wood floors underscore the loft look as do the big open-plan bathrooms clothed in tavertine marble and outfitted with rain showers in gigantic stalls. Furnishings are stylish and spare — a sleek blonde wood desk, twin night tables and black curtains dressing those big windows. Suites feel like small apartments, so much so that the hotel pitches them as backdrops for filming and photoshoots on the website.

Food and drink: The good-looking Bar Downstairs and Kitchen serves breakfast and dinner with an emphasis on locally sourced foods from the Hudson Valley — trust us, a good thing. The look is woody, moody and comfortable. Menus change with the seasons. Drinks are stylish, au courant and potent.

Amenities: Like other links in the Andaz chain, the 5th Avenue is, as mentioned, user friendly: lobby water and coffee, minibar snacks and drinks (sans beer and hard liquor), WiFi, phone calls and newspapers are all comp. The fitness center is well equipped.

Surroundings: An excellent lower midtown location directly across from the New York Public Library and Bryant Park. Times Square is a short walk away as is Grand Central Station. The Empire State Building is 12 blocks away. For shopping, Fifth Avenue haunts like Saks Fifth Avenue, Bergdorf Goodman and Tiffany & Co. up the street and Macy’s is not far from the Empire State Building. Bus stops are nearby and it’s easy to zip down to Greenwich Village, SoHo, Chinatown and the Financial District. It’s equally easy to walk over to Madison Avenue and ride uptown to the Upper East Side, Museum Mile (the Metropolitan Museum, Guggenheim, Frick Collection and others) and Central Park. Subways are a short walk away.

Back story: Though you’d never guess from the inside, the building started out in 1916 as a department store – the last and largest of the Rogers, Peet & Co., to be precise, before becoming the global headquarters for Tommy Hilfiger. Public spaces are still a bit ungainly in places, as is often the case with re-appropriated buildings. But guest rooms have a loft-like feel. The Fifth Avenue hotel, New York City’s second Andaz and aptly, the chain’s fifth link, opened in July, 2010. Pre-Covid the hotel had an artist-in-residence program that tapped for lucky contemporary artists a year to paint a mural on the doors of the Bar Downstairs — and get a suite at the hotel to call home while on the job. We’d love to see that reinstated.

Keep in mind: Fans of minimalism will click best with the decor. And to reiterate, there’s that daily service fee, though it can be easy to make it up bike rentals, restaurant discounts and in-room movies if you’re so inclined.

Andaz 5th Avenue

485 5th Avenue at 41st Street
New York, New York, USA, 10017

Tel: +1 212 601 1234

Website