All You Need To Know About Tipping at NYC Hotels

Don’t tip the Yotel robot

We’ll never know the identity of the enterprising employee who cleared his throat, stared down a guest and was remunerated for carrying a bag. But by the 1820s tipping the porter, like signing the register, was a ritual at hotels in New York and other big American cities.

Blame it on the buildings. Carrying bags wasn’t a problem for guests staying at small, squat colonial inns and taverns. But hotel architecture changed in the 1790s, with the advent of full-fledged hotels with complicated floor plans, writes A.K. Sandoval-Strausz in Hotel, An American History, a fascinating look at the evolution of the hotel.

With the first two floors consumed by an expansive lobby, grand ballrooms and spacious dining areas, guest rooms were relegated to the floors above. It became clear that guests would need help with their bags. (Elevators, aka “vertical railways,” didn’t appear until 1859 and were so costly only top-notch hotels had them.)

Enter the “rotunda men,” a new category of hotel employee first mentioned in the 1820s but probably around a lot longer. (The term bellhop originated in 1850s when the desk bell became the accepted way of calling porters.)

And tips? Routinely requested and routinely given. Hotels often forbade the practice, but wages were low, and workers won out. As the early 19th-century British tourist Emily Faithful noted, “The traveler who expects to be comfortable in an American hotel without a free distribution of dollars will soon be disenchanted . . . “

What about today? Tips are factored into hotel worker wages, so they’re expected – and appreciated. How much should you tip? NYCGo, the city’s official travel site, suggests $1 for hailing a cab, $1 to $2 per bag and $1 to $2 per — or as much as $5 — a day for housekeeping.

Not every hotel helper gets a tip. It costs $2 for the Yobot at the new Yotel Times Square to grab your bag and store it. That’s what you’d tip the porter if you’re so inclined. Consider it a mandatory tip for the ‘bot.





8 replies
  1. Stuart
    Stuart says:

    Thanks for the tipping guide and for the history. Who knew, other than A.K. Sandoval-Strausz? . . . Architecture is destiny, it seems.

  2. Susan Kim
    Susan Kim says:

    Loved the tipping trivia. One thing I would add is when you tip the maid– be sure to do it every day and not leave it for the end of your stay because the weekend maid could end up with the entire tip even though she cleaned your room the last day.

  3. Jim
    Jim says:

    Thanks for the history! Yeah tipping isn’t something we Kiwis remember, as not our way of doing things, so it’s sometimes forgotten about…

    • Terry
      Terry says:

      So true, Jim — tipping customs do vary country by country. When I lived in Tokyo, I never tipped cab drivers, who acted insulted if you tried (yet with their white gloves, immaculate cabs and automatic doors deserved tips more than most). Thanks for writing.


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.