webby honoree

New York City hotel tax is 14.75 percent plus a daily $2 per room occupancy fee. Our site lists the starting low season rack rate for each hotel, but prices rise and fall depending upon the season and demand, like airline tickets; use these rates as guidelines. Prices are lowest in January and February and highest in September and October.

It’s easy to find reviews on our site. If you know the name of the hotel you want, type it into the Keyword Search box and hit GO. If you’re looking for a hotel in a particular neighborhood, want a place that’s hip and allows pets, or crave a spa and free WiFi, check the proper criteria. For a master list of all the hotels we’ve reviewed, click Hotels A to Z. And if you don’t see the hotel you want, check in again. We’re adding new reviews every week.

New York City has more than 200 hotels in its five boroughs, and we’ll review as many as we can to help you choose. We’re independent, with no ties to hotels, booking agencies or travel agents. We pay when we eat and stay (and never mention we’re writing a review). Visit us often; we’re adding and updating reviews all the time.

To reach us, contact info@overnightnewyork.com

Hotel reviews A to Z

Search by keyword

OR Search by criteria


  gym   bar   brunch
  pool   free wifi   pets
  spa   dining   kids

City Club Hotel

55 West 44th Street between Fifth and Sixth avenues

New York, NY 10036






City Club Hotel


Updated: Jul 09, 2016


id: stylish boutique hotel

size: 65 rooms

luxury level: luxury level 30

atmosphere: quiet

‘hood: midtown west

room windows open: yes

parking: no

price: from $199

cool detail: room service from db Bistro Moderne

hotel photo

By Terry Trucco

At a glance: As a longtime fan of London’s townhouse hotels -- clubby, comfy places usually owned by a family or individual -- I like City Club’s vibe. It’s small (65 rooms), stylish (blue-chip decorator Jeffrey Bilhuber was the original designer), and the staff know your name (usually).

Still, it’s easy to be underwhelmed when you enter. The white, window-lined lobby is as quiet as a convent, as big as a pocket and there’s almost no place to sit (owner Jeff Klein told an interviewer he wanted his lobby to be the antithesis of the night-clubby Royalton across the street, and boy, oh boy, he got it).

The small mezzanine sitting area with a square donut-style hole cut out to overlook the lobby is airy and inviting though, sadly, not as chic as it once was. I like the witty Regency armchairs upholstered in creamy damask. And I like how they’re juxtaposed with mid-century mod trappings.

But those serviceable white-clothed tables leave me cold. Alas, they didn't disappear with the hotel's most recent renovation, which lavished much-neded attention on the rooms. But we live in hope.

Cool detail: Framed record albums and vintage Playbills are on view throughout the hotel, a nod to the neighborhood’s deep ties to Tin Pan Alley and Broadway theater.

Rooms: Ranging from teeny (195 square feet) to a grand-scale 750 square foot duplex, rooms are urban, masculine and chic. The smallest have space (barely) for a queen-size bed and built-in shelves holding a fun selection of travel books. But king-bed rooms -- almost spacious and uniformly stylish -- sport banquettes in front of the lead-paned windows. Bathrooms, encased in chocolate marble, are surprisingly big and luxe (small rooms have a stall shower and a bidet). Craving space? The duplexes (there are three) have magnificent floor-through windows, balconies and remind me of that classic New York apartment in Alfred Hitchcock’s Rope.

Cool detail: Cookies at turndown.

Food and drink: A big plus: db Bistro Moderne, Daniel Boulud’s high-style, high-vibe French bistro --- home of the vaunted $36 truffle burger (messy but scrumptious) --- is the hotel restaurant and provides room service. But the restaurant’s double dining rooms are so appealing – even if they're looking a bit dated -- it’s more fun to come downstairs, sit at a banquette, mingle with the stylish crowd, and sip a glass of hibiscus iced tea (the bright red flowers in a photo on the wall match the tea). I brunched on a flavorful spring risotto with vegetables and shrimp and cinnamon cake with a tiny scoop of gelato ($26 for two courses) paired with decent coffee and excellent service. At $45, the three-course pre-theater prix fixe dinner is a sweet deal.

Amenities: Free Wi-Fi and name-brand goodies: Frette bed linens, C.O. Bigelow toiletries, bathroom speakers so you can listen to the news while you wash your face. There’s no health club on the premises, but guests can use New York Sports Club ($20 fee per visit). Discounted parking available at a nearby parking garage ($35 a day; call hotel for details). Pets allowed, 25 lbs. and under ($100 deposit, refunded if no damage occurs).

Surroundings: West 44th Street between Fifth and Sixth avenues is known as Club Row (the a lineup includes Harvard, Marnier, Penn and more). Times Square and the Theater District, Grand Central Station, Bryant Park, Fifth Avenue shopping and the New York Public Library are steps away. Though farther afield, Rockefeller Center, the Museum of Modern Art and Lincoln Center are easy to reach as are, in the opposite direction, the Empire State Building and Madison Square Garden. Subway stops are several short blocks away, and bus stops are even closer.

Back story: The City Club originated in 1904 as a gentlemen’s club designed to encourage nonpartisan political discussion (noble thought). Despite years as an office building and headquarters for the American Plywood Association, the original design still survives. The duplex suites were once a ballroom. And the teeny rooms? They were quarters for members’ butlers. Owner Jeff Klein, a socially connected New Yorker and hotel geek, refurbished the place lovingly in 2001. Check out his New York Times blog from January 2008.

Keep in mind: Small rooms are teeny as are most closets (how many outfits did the butler need?).

What We Saw:




Your Name: